is allah a Liar ? please help ...

[muslim184]

بسمـ اللــــه الـــ ــرحمــ ــن الـــرحـــ يــ مـ


الــسلام علــــــــيــكـم و رحـــمـــة اللـــــــه و بـــــركاتـــه





أطلب مساعدتكم في الإجابة على الأسئلة في هذا المقطع
(لمن يتقن اللغة الإنجليزية)

is allah a Liar ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I26nkXEclYw

[المعتوق]

You've asked this in the other forum and you got answered. For the purpose of clarity I will copy the answer here.

[muslim184]

Where is the answer ? i want it in english , please

[المعتوق]

Salam Aleekom,
Apologies, I have got carried away and started replying via comments on youtube. I will copy them here for archive as I suspect the video uploader may just delete them.


At 00:00:44 You said, "Why God says in the bible that Jesus is his Son? Jn 3:16" If you read the bible, it was not Jesus who said that, it was John, the presumed writer of that gospel, which if you dig deeper you'll find that it was inspired by the gospel of Mark and the name and details of the original author of the 4th gospel is unknown and is in dispute.
Nothing in John 1 says that that Gospel is the word of God, it was the church fathers who chose it and claimed it to be the word of God.


At 00:01:01 You asked if the bible is the word of God according to the Quran. Your answer is misleading. The short answer is, yes it WAS the word of God when it was revealed to Jesus PBUH (The current gospels tell us that he preached the bible - which of the 4 bibles did he preach?? He preached the gospel that was revealed to Jesus PBUH - simple truth ) Then those entrusted with keeping it changed it to suit their worldly desires. So it became polluted and corrupted.




Can I also add that you're selectively not quoting the whole verses to suit your needs. Are you really wanting the truth or are you one of those false prophets that comes in sheep's clothing saying I love you?


at 00:02:31 You're asking if the bible was changed before/after the Quran. I refer you to the Psalm 51, one of the most famous Psalms attributed to David PBUH. Why does it talk about the rebuild of Jerusalem? When Jerusalem was destroyed after Jesus? The answer is that it was added after Jesus.


At 00:02:41 The answer is in the bible. God entrusted the Jews & the followers of Christ to upkeep the bible. Rom 3:2 Much in every way! First of all, the Jews have been entrusted with the very words of God. & 1 Thessalonians 2:4 But as we have been approved by God to be entrusted with the gospel, even so we speak, not as pleasing men, but God who tests our hearts.God did not entrust men to upkeep the Quran. Quran 15:9 Indeed, it is We who sent down the Qur'an and indeed, We will be its guardian



I think these comments are enough to start a real conversation if you wish. If you want to delete my comments. I have delivered the message and you are responsible and accountable for your actions on the day of judgement.

[المعتوق]

Jazak Allah Khair for pointing the video out. although I suspect it may be a lost battle as the uploader controls the comments.

[المعتوق]

I've added more comments to my nickname is SeekingTheTruthWorld can you help by making my comments positive, they are being flagged as spam by the video maker and his friends.
The yourtube video is v=I26nkXEclYw

[muslim184]

Thank you so much ! May Allah accept our good works..aameen

[muslim184]

i know that he is removing our comments because he is a coward .. i got an idea , how about making a reply video ? i will try to make it .. thanks for helping !